Desserts, Ice Cream & Other Cool Treats

Pumpkin Frozen Yogurt

7 Comments 11 September 2013

I saw a post Sis Blogging Partner made or shared on Facebook the other day about a pumpkin frozen yogurt recipe and proceeded to have the longest Facebook convo of my life to date. Obviously the idea of pumpkin frozen yogurt was appealing to us! Since there’s no time like the present, we got on that like a dog on a meaty bone, except this was a little more about the healthy side of things. The recipe we found seemed a little underwhelming for the effort, though, so we tried the following recipe from the blog, A Sweet Pea Chef.

Pumpkin Frozen Yogurt-1

Let’s see a show of hands for those who’ve felt Fall in the air recently. Mine are way up. What…it’s still in the 90s most days? Oh yeah, sure, the humidity it still trying to strangle us, but – but! It’s been so much cooler in the mornings, and the air at night feels a little more crisp. Folks, it’s on. The countdown to Fall is here! Oh, September 22, you are a beautiful thing.

Pumpkin Frozen Yogurt-2

An even healthier way to go with this frozen treat is to not add much of any sugar, but the last time I looked, I mean tasted, Greek yogurt is a really tart thing and pumpkin, while distinct, is also very plain. The two need a sweetener (or two) to help them reach their peak appealing best. I had some of this praline maple syrup on hand, so in it went!

Pumpkin Frozen Yogurt-3

After the sweeteners (brown sugar as well, folks), pumpkin and yogurt, you just mix in the usual pumpkin pie spice suspects: cinnamon, ground cloves and ground nutmeg. Yes, you can use fresh-grated nutmeg. Yes, you could use a pumpkin pie spice blend if you already have it on hand, just be sure to add a little at a time and taste test to see if you want more. Start with, say, half a teaspoon and go from there.

Pumpkin Frozen Yogurt-4

At this point, stir everything till fully incorporated and taste it to see if you want it sweeter, more cinnamony, more nutmegy – you get the idea. Be the master of your own pumpkin frozen yogurt flavor!

Pumpkin Frozen Yogurt-5

Into one of those cute little counter top ice cream makers the mixture goes! We added a half cup more pumpkin puree than called for the get a little stronger pumpkin flavor, and the whole mixture was just enough for my Cuisinart ice cream churner. Alternately, you can place the mixture in a freezer safe container, covered, and stir it every so often till it’s thickened enough to serve. I have no personal experience doing this method, but many recipes suggest it as an alternative to an ice cream churner. The churner gets it to a semi-soft consistency, but it too will still need some freezer time to get more firm.

Pumpkin Frozen Yogurt-7

And after pretty little effort, this is what you get! A really creamy, pumpkiny-good, Fall-inspired bowl of yum. Admittedly, it was really tangy, but hey, it depends a lot on the brand of yogurt you use, and next time I might just sweeten it a little more. As per usual, though, it’s a good recipe that you can tailor to your specific tastes. Want to avoid some of the sweetener? Leave it out. It’s that easy, and it’s now that much easier to enjoy Fall in a somewhat healthier way at least. Because the comfort food parade, it is coming!

Pumpkin Frozen Yogurt

from Pumpkin Frozen Yogurt with Roasted Pecans by A Sweet Pea Chef (A superb food blog – check it out!)

Prep Time: 10 minutes    Chill Time: 3-4 hours    Level: Easy    Makes: 1 1/2 to 2 quarts

1 quart (32 ounces) vanilla yogurt
1 cup pumpkin puree
1/3 cup pure maple syrup
1/3 cup brown sugar
1/2 tsp. vanilla extract
1/2 tsp. ground cinnamon
1/2 tsp. ground nutmeg
1/2 tsp. ground cloves
1/2 cup whole raw pecans (optional)

To roast the pecans, heat the oven to 350 degrees. Spread whole raw pecans over a baking sheet lined with parchment paper or aluminum foil. Bake pecans for 4-5 minutes. Remove pan from the oven and stir the pecans to toss around. Bake for an additional 3 to 5 minutes, or until the pecans begin to give off a sweet scent. Allow to cool and then chop or crush pecans.

In a large mixing bowl, combine all the ingredients (minus the pecans) and mix well.  Using a whisk will help to break up the possible lumps in the mixture.  Taste for flavoring.  If too sweet, add more yogurt or pumpkin puree.  If not pumpkin-y enough, add more pumpkin puree.  If not sweet enough, add equal parts maple syrup and brown sugar.

Pour mixture into a prepared ice cream maker and follow the manufacturer’s guide. Freeze for at least 3-4 hours prior to serving.

Top with chopped roasted pecans when serving.


You may be wondering – hey, where’s your pecans, you food hussies?! And you would be correct, we forgot the pecans! We actually didn’t intend to roast them, but we did mean to throw some raw ones on top of the ice cream, cuz – yum. We just didn’t want to heat up the oven to roast them, and then forgot by the time the yogurt was firm enough to scoop up to use raw ones. Oopsies.

I was psyched to try this recipe because I still have pumpkin puree I made last Fall in the freezer, and yes, it’s still perfectly good. It may have a slightly less strong pumpkin flavor though than the canned variety, but know your own puree will work fine if you have any.

Last but not least, and this may be a duh kind of note to make, but if you have a wide freezer-safe container that will fit in your freezer at the time, the shallower your yogurt is in the container, the quicker it will freeze. I ended up using a bigger, wider container than I was originally going to, and our yogurt was actually ready in about two hours.

You don’t have to use Greek yogurt, but I do like it for its exceptionally creamy consistency. Even the fat free variety is very creamy. My experiences with this are the Chobani brand shown and Fage. Cabot also makes a wonderful vanilla bean greek-style yogurt that would probably work, though it’s not nearly as thick as the others. All are very tart, so remember that when sweetening yours.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email


- who has written 347 posts on Full Fork Ahead.

Wife, mom, indulgent reader and Day Job Do-er, who occasionally likes to think she can cook. Sometimes she's right, sometimes she's wrong.

Contact the author

Your Comments

7 Comments so far

  1. Pumpkin before September 22nd–even when it’s 90 degrees (or 100 where I am in Arizona!)–is a wonderful thing. 🙂 This looks delicious! I just got a bunch of Chobani and my new roommate brought an ice cream maker… this might be on the list of things to make soon. 🙂

  2. Hy
    mmm, Thank you for this great recipe

  3. Jann says:

    Just made his with Vanilla LF yogurt. Sometimes Greek Yogurt is too tart for my taste. Since I don’t care for maple flavoring, I used honey. Next time I’ll leave out the cloves. I found it was a little overpowering.


  1. Smexy’s Top Ten–September 13 | Smexy Books - September 13, 2013

    […] MMMMMM. Frozen Pumpkin Yogurt from Full Fork Ahead. I’m SO ready for fall. Pumpkin yogurt and pumpkin beer. It’s good […]

  2. Reasons To Be Ready For Fall: Our Top 5 | Full Fork Ahead - September 18, 2013

    […] it’s still a little hot where you are, and likely to be into the Fall, this Pumpkin Frozen Yogurt is a great way to get your pumpkin in! Make it to taste, sweetening it as much as or little as you […]

  3. An Edible Mosaic™ » 100+ Pumpkin Spice Recipes Perfect for Fall - October 6, 2014

    […] Pumpkin Frozen Yogurt from Full Fork […]

Share your view

Post a comment

Subscribe without commenting


Recipes used here do not belong to Full Fork Ahead. Please check each post for the source. We review recipes, photograph our efforts and comment on our experiences with the recipes only. Please contact us if you have any questions.

Photos on flickr

Subscribe to the Goodness

Enter an email address to subscribe to Full Fork Ahead & receive delicious news in your inbox.

Join 280 other subscribers

© 2018 Full Fork Ahead. Powered by WordPress.

Daily Edition Theme by WooThemes - Premium WordPress Themes

%d bloggers like this: